Microtonal, just intonation, electronic music software Microtonal, just intonation, electronic music software

Encyclopedia of Microtonal Music Theory

@ 00 A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
Login   |  Encyclopedia Index

31-tone equal-temperament / 31-edo / 31-ET

[Joe Monzo]

31-tone equal-temperament in standard meantone notation

31-et in standard meantone staff-notation

Below is a tabulation of approximate cents values for 31-edo, arranged in descending scalar order:

                 31-edo
-- note name --  degree     ~cents
 C ............... 31     1200
             B# .. 30     1161.290323
 Cb .............. 29     1122.580645
             B ... 28     1083.870968
           Ax .... 27     1045.16129
             Bb .. 26     1006.451613
           A# .... 25      967.7419355
             Bbb . 24      929.0322581
           A ..... 23      890.3225806
         Gx ...... 22      851.6129032
           Ab .... 21      812.9032258
         G# ...... 20      774.1935484
           Abb ... 19      735.483871
         G ....... 18      696.7741935
       Fx ........ 17      658.0645161
         Gb ...... 16      619.3548387
       F# ........ 15      580.6451613
         Gbb ..... 14      541.9354839
       F ......... 13      503.2258065
     E# .......... 12      464.516129
       Fb ........ 11      425.8064516
     E ........... 10      387.0967742
   Dx ............  9      348.3870968
     Eb ..........  8      309.6774194
   D# ............  7      270.9677419
     Ebb .........  6      232.2580645
   D .............  5      193.5483871
 Cx ..............  4      154.8387097
   Db ............  3      116.1290323
 C# ..............  2       77.41935484
   Dbb ...........  1       38.70967742
 C ...............  0        0
				

Each equal-temperament belongs to several different temperament families, based on the particular promos which it tempers out. 31-edo is historically one of the most important, primarily because it is a member of the meantone family, and in particular because it closely resembles 1/4-comma meantone. Note that because 31-edo's cardinality is a prime-number, any of 31-edo's intervals may be used as a generator to generate the entire tuning.

. . . . . . . . .
31-edo as approximation of 1/4-comma meantone

Meantone temperaments are classified as "linear temperaments", and belong to the category of linear temperaments called "chain of 5ths" tunings, because they are analagous to the long-traditional pythagorean tuning, in that they use a generator which is a type of "perfect-5th", albeit one which is tempered so that its interval size is slightly smaller than the "pure" pythagorean "5th" (the pythagorean "5th" is ~702 cents). Using "C" as the name for the reference pitch, any "chain of 5ths" tuning (i.e., any tuning which uses a generator which is that tuning's version of the "perfect-5th") may be schematically illustrated as follows:

note names:           Bb   F   C   G   D   A   E   B  F#
                 ... --+---+---+---+---+---+---+---+---+-- ...
generator-5ths:       -2  -1   0  +1  +2  +3  +4  +5  +6
				

As can be seen from the tabulation of 31-edo cents values above, the closest approximation to the pythagorean "5th" in 31-edo is given by 18 degrees of 31-edo, an interval with a ratio of ~1.495517882 and a logarithmic size of ~696.7741935 cents.

All meantone tunings contain subsets which are diatonic scales consisting of two different "step" sizes, a "Large" and a "small", which may be designated L and s. In all meantone tunings, the large interval (L) is the "whole-step" or "whole-tone", the interval of a "major 2nd", and is found by traversing +2 generator "5ths" and reducing by 1 octave; thus, in 31-edo, the L is:

C = n0

first, stack 2 generator "5ths":

     8ve  gen         ~ratio              ~cents      31-edo degrees
                 2(((18*gen)/31)+8ve)

  G   [ 0  +1]        1.495517882         696.7741935       18
+ 5th [ 0  +1]      * 1.495517882      +  696.7741935     + 18
--------------      -------------      --------------     ----
  D   [ 0  +2]        2.236573736        1393.548387        36    =  2 generator "5ths" (= major-9th)


then, reduce by 1 octave to normalize:

     8ve  gen         ~ratio              ~cents      31-edo degrees
                 2(((18*gen)/31)+8ve)

  D   [ 0  +2]        2.236573736        1393.5483871       36
- 8ve [ 1   0]      ÷ 2                - 1200             - 31
--------------      -------------      --------------     ----
  D   [-1  +2]        1.118286868         193.5483871        5    =  major-2nd = L
				

Here is another example, which uses notes derived from +1 and -1 generators, where the -1 generator has already been octave normalized:

C = n0
     8ve  gen         ~ratio              ~cents      31-edo degrees
                 2(((18*gen)/31)+8ve)                    ((18*gen) mod 31)

  G  [ 0  +1]        1.495517882         696.7741935        18
- F  [+1  -1]     ÷  1.337329378       - 503.2258065      - 13
-------------      -------------      ---------------     ----
  *  [-1  +2]        1.118286868         193.5483871         5



  * This always results in a change of letter-name.
				

This is the "mean-tone" which occurs almost exactly midway between the two just-intonation "whole-tones" with ratios of 10:9 and 9:8. (The exact mean-tone is that of 1/4-comma meantone.)

By continuing the process of stacking generators and normalizing, one may obtain the diatonic major scale. As an example, on the linear lattice-diagram illustrated above, the C-major scale appears as a subset of the lattice, between generators -1 and +5 inclusive. Regardless of the actual pitches (frequencies, or ratios, or cents values, etc.), the major scale whose tonic is the reference pitch (in this case, C) maps this way in any chain-of-5ths tuning.

In the table below, the "8ve" (octaves) and "gen" (generator 5ths) columns on the left show the generic [period, generator] mapping of pitches in the C-major scale for all members of the meantone family, and the "~ratio", "~cents", and "31-edo degrees" columns show the values associated with the mapping of the C-major scale specific to 31-edo:

C = n0
     8ve  gen         ~ratio              ~cents      31-edo degrees
                 2(((18*gen)/31)+8ve)                    ((18*gen) mod 31)

  B  [-2   5]        1.870243098        1083.870968        28
  A  [-1   3]        1.672418009         890.3225806       23
  G  [ 0   1]        1.495517882         696.7741935       18
  F  [ 1  -1]        1.337329378         503.2258065       13
  E  [-2   4]        1.25056552          387.0967742       10
  D  [-1   2]        1.118286868         193.5483871        5
  C  [ 0   0]        1                     0                0

    (compare the "gen" values with those in the "chain of 5ths" linear lattice-diagram above)
				

In all meantone tunings, the small interval (s) is the "half-step", which is also the diatonic-semitone and the interval of a "minor 2nd", and is found by traversing -5 generator "5ths" (which is equivalent to +5 generator "4ths"). As can be seen in the "chain of 5ths" schematic above, this may be found twice in any major scale: between the octave above the tonic (reference note) and the leading-tone or major-7th, and also between the perfect-4th and the major-3rd. In 31-edo, the s is thus:

C = n0


s between octave and major-7th:

     8ve  gen         ~ratio              ~cents      31-edo degrees
                 2(((18*gen)/31)+8ve)

  C  [+1   0]        2.                  1200               31
- B  [-2  +5]     ÷  1.870243098       - 1083.870968      - 28
-------------      -------------      ---------------     ----
  *  [+3  -5]        1.069379699          116.1290323        3




s between perfect-4th and major-3rd:

     8ve  gen         ~ratio              ~cents      31-edo degrees
                 2(((18*gen)/31)+8ve)                    ((18*gen) mod 31)

  F  [+1  -1]        1.337329378         503.2258065        13
- E  [-2  +4]     ÷  1.25056552        - 387.0967742      - 10
-------------      -------------      ---------------     ----
  *  [+3  -5]        1.069379699         116.1290323         3



  * This always results in a change of letter-name.
				

In both historical chronology and the method of scale construction by generators, the chromatic-semitone first emerges in meantone as the interval between B and Bb:

C = n0
     8ve  gen          ~ratio              ~cents      31-edo degrees
                 2(((18*gen)/31)+8ve)                    ((18*gen) mod 31)

  Bb [+2  -2]        1.788449866        1006.451613         26
- B  [-2  +5]      ÷ 1.870243098      - 1083.870968       - 28
-------------      -------------      ---------------     ----
   b [+4  -7]        0.956265989         -77.41935484       29 = -2 mod 31
				

The "round-b" or "soft-b" was used to notate Bb, and eventually evolved into the "flat" symbol, defined as above. This signifies a flattening (lowering in pitch) by 2 degrees of 31-edo.

B-natural was notated as "square-b" or "hard-b". Gradually, as the scale was extended, this "square-b" evolved into both the "natural" and "sharp" symbols, and also resulted in the Eastern European practice of calling "B-flat" simply "b", with "B-natural" called "h".

C = n0
     8ve  gen         ~ratio              ~cents      31-edo degrees
                 2(((18*gen)/31)+8ve)                    ((18*gen) mod 31)

  F# [-3  +6]        1.398490998         580.6451613         15
- F  [+1  -1]     ÷  1.337329378       - 503.2258065       - 13
-------------      -------------      ---------------      ----
   # [-4  +7]        1.045734148         +77.41935484         2
			

This is the interval of the "augmented unison" or "augmented prime", also known as the "chromatic semitone", and signifies a sharpening (raising in pitch) by 2 degrees of 31-edo.

Extending the system still further, to Eb -3 on the flat side and to D# +9 on the sharp side, we find a smaller interval, the "diminished 2nd":

C = n0
     8ve  gen         ~ratio              ~cents      31-edo degrees
                 2(((18*gen)/31)+8ve)                    ((18*gen) mod 31)

  Eb [+2  -3]        1.195873274         309.6774194          8
- D# [-5  +9]     ÷  1.169430766       - 270.9677419        - 7
-------------      -------------      ---------------      ----
     [+7 -12]        1.022611436          38.70967742         1
			

Extending the system still further, to Cb -7 on the flat side and to B# +12 on the sharp side, we find a new interval, the "augmented 7th" minus an "8ve", which, in 31-edo, is exactly the same size as the "diminished 2nd" discovered above:

C = n0
     8ve   gen         ~ratio               ~cents      31-edo degrees
                  2(((18*gen)/31)+8ve)                    ((18*gen) mod 31)

  B# [ -6 +12]        1.95577707         1161.290323         30
- Cb [ +5  -7]     ÷  1.912531979      - 1122.580645       - 29
--------------      -------------     ----------------     ----
     [-11 +19]        1.022611436          38.70967742        1
			

Finally, extending the system to Cbb -14 on the flat side and Ax +17 on the sharp side, we find the point where the system closes:

C = n0
      8ve   gen         ~ratio              ~cents      31-edo degrees
                   2(((18*gen)/31)+8ve)                    ((18*gen) mod 31)

  Cbb [ +9 -14]        1.828889285        1045.16129         27
- Ax  [ -9 +17]     ÷  1.828889285      - 1045.16129       - 27
---------------      -------------      ------------       ----
      [+18 -31]        1                     0                0
			

Below is a diagram of the 31-edo "circle-of-5ths" in this typical meantone usage, giving the 31-edo degree-numbers in the cubes and the letter-name notation alongside, showing the closure of the system between Gbb -13 = Ex +18 generators and Cbb -14 = Ax +17 generators:

31-et circle-of-5ths

Below is a pitch-height graph of the complete 31-edo circle-of-5ths, shown as a meantone chain, centered on C. The red arrows connect the enharmonically equivalent notes at each end of the chain which are exactly the same pitch.

31-edo meantone chain, pitch-height graph

Below is the same circle-of-5ths-as-meantone-chain, shown on the regular 5-line staff notation, with a slur connecting the enharmonically equivalent notes.

31-edo meantone chain, standard staff notation

Below is a circular diagram of 31-edo with letter notation of its typical meantone usage, showing the degrees of 31-edo arranged according to pitch-height scalar order around the circle which represents the "8ve".

31-et circle of scale degrees

31-et circle-of-scale-degrees

When used as a meantone, 31-edo is also intended to approximate ratios containing prime-factor 5 -- thus, a lattice of the just-intonation pitches being approximated becomes planar (2-dimensional) rather than simply linear (1-dimensional), i.e., another dimension is added to represent prime-factor 5. Below is a 2-dimensional 5-limit bingo-card lattice-diagram, showing a typical periodicity tiling of the 31-edo representations of 5-limit ratios, with a typical spelling in a chain from Gbb at -13 generators to Ax at +17 generators where C=n0 -- it would be difficult to find music from the "common-practice" (c. 1600-1900) repertoire which has notes falling outside this range.

Exponents of 3 run across the top row and exponents of 5 run in a column down the left side; C n0 is outlined in heavy black; syntonic-comma equivalents (which have the same spelling) are in a light shade of grey; enharmonically-equivalent pitches (which have a different spelling but are the same pitch as those in the central block) are in a darker shade of grey. Integers designate the degrees of 31-edo.

31-et bingo-card lattice showing letters and periodic tiling

When used as a meantone, 31-edo provides not only a circle of "5ths" (i.e., tempered approximation of the 3:2 ratio), but also a circle of "major-3rds" (i.e., tempered approximation of the 5:4 ratio) -- in our example C-based lattice, this circle can be spelled C-E-G#-B#-Fbb-Abb-Cb-Eb-G-B-D#-Fx-Cbb-Ebb-Gb-Bb-D-F#-A#-Cx-Gbb-Bbb-Db-F-A-C#-E#-Gx-Dbb-Fb-Ab-C. The closed geometry which represents both of these circles simultaneously takes the form of a torus, with both circles twisted to form two interconnected spirals which outline the surface of the torus. Below is a graphic adapted from a Musica lattice (based on A instead of C), showing 31-edo as a torus, with the circle of 5ths as a closed tight spiral colored magenta, and the other closed spiral, representing major-3rds, wider and colored green.

31-edo 3,5-primespace toroidal lattice

31-edo meantone chain, 2-color Musica torus lattice

(Be aware that 31-edo also belongs to other temperament families! ... namely, miracle, würschmidt, and orwell.)

. . . . . . . . .
Some rational convergents to the 31-edo degrees
31=0 2:1 = 1:1
30 43:22 , 45:23 , 88:45 , 133:68 , 221:113 , 575:294
29 21:11 , 44:23 , 153:80
28 15:8 , 43:23 , 101:54 , 245:131
27 11:6 , 64:35 , 139:76 , 342:187 , 481:263
26 9:5 , 25:14 , 34:19 , 59:33 , 93:52
25 7:4 , 397:227
24 12:7 , 53:31 , 65:38, 118:69 , 183:107 , 301:176
23 5:3 , 97:58
22 18:11 , 157:96
21 8:5 , 435:272 , 443:277
20 11:7 , 25:16 , 61:39 , 208:133
19 26:17
18 3:2 , 166:111
17 19:13 , 117:80 , 253:173 , 370:253
16 10:7 , 123:86 , 133:93
15 7:5 , 186:133
14 11:8 , 15:11 , 26:19 , 67:49 , 93:68 , 253:185
13 4:3 , 111:83
12 17:13
11 9:7 , 23:18 , 55:43 , 78:61 , 133:104
10 5:4
9 11:9 , 192:157
8 6:5 , 55:46 , 116:97
7 7:6 , 69:59 , 283:242 , 352:301
6 8:7 , 223:195 , 231:202
5 9:8 , 19:17 , 85:76 , 104:93
4 11:10 , 12:11 , 35:32 , 152:139 , 187:171
3 15:14 , 31:29 , 77:72 , 185:173 , 262:245
2 22:21 , 23:22 , 160:153
1 42:41 , 43:42 , 44:43 , 45:44 , 181:177
0 1:1
progressing to the right = greater accuracy of approximation and greater complexity